A love story that shaped a city: The amazing piece of history hidden in Fort Lauderdale

Bride: Ivy Julia Cromartie in the outfit she wore for her marriage to Frank Stranahan in 1900 (Picture: Fort Lauderdale Historical Society)

Driving along the sprawling freeways past vast developments towards the towering ocean-front hotels of Fort Lauderdale, it’s hard to imagine that, a little over a century ago, this was a desolate area full of swamps, wildcats, alligators and sharks.

Many of the thousands of holidaymakers who arrive here to enjoy the beaches or take a Caribbean cruise from Port Everglades have no idea that tucked away next to a huge shopping mall is a piece of history that stands in memorial to two remarkable people who took a leading part in shaping this city.

Day out: Young Ivy poses for photographer Frank on one of their scenic boat rides up New River (Picture: Fort Lauderdale Historical Society/Stranahan Collection)

This riverside house was the home of Frank and Ivy Stranahan. He was a pioneer, originally from Iowa, who set up a trading post with the Seminole Indians in 1893 when only three other white people lived nearby.

Ivy, who died only in 1971, arrived by the early train on October 1, 1899, as an 18-year-old teacher, when the settlement of New River had grown to five families and nine pupils.

Together: Ivy and Frank Stranahan read the newspaper in their yard, late 1910s-1920s (Picture: Fort Lauderdale Historical Society)

They married within 12 months, despite Frank being 16 years older than his bride. It had to be a dawn ceremony as the newlyweds caught a 6am train that was to take them on honeymoon as far as Niagara Falls and into Canada.

The next year, Frank built them a home – today known as Stranahan House – where they continued to trade with the Seminoles, selling hunting rifles, tools, food and sewing machines in return for wild animal pelts and even live baby alligators.

Visitors: A Seminole man and woman with a dog, near Frank Stranahan’s trading post in the 1890s (Picture: Fort Lauderdale Historical Society/Stranahan Collection)

The visiting Indians would sleep on the verandah, children would visit the local cinema, and Ivy – who they called ‘Little White Mother’ – would teach them Sunday school. Frank never drove a car but Ivy acquired a Model-T Ford which she steered along rutted roads to visit the Seminoles and give classes.

In 1911, the growing city was named Fort Lauderdale after a military outpost set up during the Seminole Wars. Frank became involved in property and banking, made a million, and took small shares in transport, rail, lumber, phone, oil and amusement companies although, in the booming twenties, he complained that ‘city life is too fast for me’.

The face of history: Ivy Cromartie Stranahan on the second floor porch of her home in 1961 (Picture: Fort Lauderdale Historical Society/Gene Hyde Collection)

Ivy, a lifelong friend of the Seminoles, also took up other causes including votes for women, the Red Cross, family planning, town planning, a gardening club and the historical society.

However, in 1929, after the banks failed and the Depression set in, Frank Stranahan weighed himself down with a grate and threw himself in the New River outside his home.

Ivy refused to accept it was suicide and scored the word out of newspaper reports she kept about the death. Devastated, she went into mourning for ten years.

In financial straits – Stranahan House had fallen in value from $600,000 to $50,000 – Ivy was forced to let out the ground floor to a restaurant. As a teetotaller, she refused to allow it to sell alcohol – but continued to live on the upper floor, taking meals with the other diners downstairs but never leaving a tip.

Pioneers’ home: Stranahan House In 1913 (Picture: Fort Lauderdale Historical Society)

Despite her personal tragedy, Ivy’s zeal for campaigning didn’t mellow. She carried on fighting, particularly for the rights of the Seminoles.

In 1956, the Miami Herald called her Fort Lauderdale’s ‘first lady’, adding that her ‘patience, diplomacy and understanding through a long career of civic work are a model for the young women who’ll shape the city’s future.’

In later years, she recalled being known as ‘Poison Ivy’ to her critics, adding: ‘I’ve been the master of my life. Now I have ceased proposing, or disposing, anything. I’ve settled down to the quiet life and only better eyesight could make me happier. I don’t seem to notice growing old. It seems the natural condition that appears just like youth, and is not to be worried over.’


Survivor: Despite all the development of Fort Lauderdale, Stranahan House still stands. Here it is decorated for Christmas (Picture: Dave Monk)

She led a successful campaign to prevent government support being removed from the Seminoles, making a personal appearance at a Senate hearing. It was to be one of her last public appeals.

Ivy, who never had children herself, died in 1971 and was buried beside her husband in a ceremony attended by native American elders.


Tribute: A sign at Stranahan House (Picture: Dave Monk)

One of the Seminoles, Betty Mae Tiger Jumper, said of her: ‘She was instrumental in a lot of ways to me and to others of the tribe in getting us to school. We owe her what knowledge we have of what is going on in the white man’s culture. She started the Friends of the Seminoles and they are glad she gave her effort and love to make our lives better. The young ones are very sorry to see her go. She was a true friend of the Seminoles.’

Outlook: The second-floor verandah where Ivy would look out to the river (Picture: Dave Monk)

A Seventh Day Adventist, Ivy left Stranahan House to the church but it was later sold to the Fort Lauderdale Historical Society, of which she was a founding member. Now the home welcomes visitors who can stand on the verandah, looking out to the river, and imagine how it must have seemed to that feisty young schoolteacher who arrived in the wilderness and helped determine a city’s history.


Plaque: This sign combines mentions of Frank Stranahan, the Seminole attack in 1836 and the origin of Fort Lauderdale (Picture: Dave Monk)

Ivy is still fondly remembered by those whose causes she championed. In 2000, a year before Stranahan House celebrated its centenary, the Seminoles pledged $3million they had made from ventures such as bingo towards creating a historical park next to the building.

In making the donation, spokesman James E Billie said: ‘Ivy Stranahan was a good friend to our tribe. We’re back to help as much as we can.’


Memorial: A sign giving the history of Stranahan House (Picture: Dave Monk)

Stranahan House lies 335 Southeast 6th Avenue, Fort Lauderdale. For more information, please click here.

Primary research from The Stranahans of Fort Lauderdale, A Pioneer Family of New River, by Harry A Kersey Jr, available on Amazon

Last post: A recreation of the first post office in Fort Lauderdale, next to Stranahan House (Picture: Dave Monk)

To donate to the Fort Lauderdale Historical Society, please click here

Finally, here is a video on the history of Fort Lauderdale:

Shipmonk has been shortlisted as best blog in the 2015 Cruise International awards. To vote, please click here (last category)

One thought on “A love story that shaped a city: The amazing piece of history hidden in Fort Lauderdale

Leave a Reply